The Forge Papers · No. 02
Number II

The Forgotten Man and the AI Revolution

Everyone agrees AI will change every industry. Almost nobody asks who it will serve, and the answer, so far, is not the man who built the country.

Adapted from the Liberty Forge white paper of the same name. This is the founding argument of the firm; it belongs at the front of the series.

A and B put their heads together to decide what C shall be made to do for D. The radical vice of all these schemes is that C is not allowed a voice in the matter, and his position, character, and interests are entirely overlooked. I call C the Forgotten Man.William Graham Sumner, 1883

The artificial intelligence revolution is here. Every big consulting firm, every technology company, every business magazine says the same thing: AI will change every industry. They are mostly right. But there is a question almost nobody is asking, and it is the only one that matters to the people I work for. Who is this revolution actually for?

The Fortune 500 will be fine. They have data scientists, research labs, and budgets with a lot of zeros. The venture-backed startups will be fine too; AI is in their blood. But what about the family farmer whose margins have gotten thinner for twenty years? The manufacturer running a two percent profit with forty people on the floor? The mother who homeschools her kids and will not hand their information to a company she has never met? The independent clinic fighting to stay open while a hospital system tries to swallow it?

These are the forgotten men and women of the AI revolution. They are the backbone of the country. They pay the taxes, build the things, and risk everything to make something real. And once again, they are being left out.

Who the forgotten man really is

William Graham Sumner wrote about the forgotten man back in 1883, and his forgotten man was never the poorest person in the room. He was the productive one: the man who works, pays his way, and carries the load, and who never gets asked what he thinks while other people decide what he owes.

Sumner told it as a little story. Two people, call them A and B, get together and decide what a third person, C, should be made to do for a fourth person, D. Everybody talks about A, B, and D. Nobody asks C. C just gets the bill. Sumner said C is the forgotten man.

Now put today's names on it. A is the platform company. B is the consulting firm. D is the shareholder, the regulator, or the vague idea we call "progress." And C, the forgotten man, is the owner of the shop, the farm, or the clinic. He gets handed a subscription, a terms-of-service agreement, and a friendly invitation to upload his records to somebody else's computer. Nobody asked him. He just got signed up.

Three gaps, not one

It is easy to say the forgotten man simply cannot afford good AI help. That is true, and it is the smallest part of the problem. There are really three gaps, and they stack.

The money gap. The AI consulting business is built for big companies. Serious projects start in the six figures, and even the smaller firms want to see a very large business before they return a call. So the owner of a shop or a farm is left with two choices: buy generic software off the shelf, or go without. The kind of custom help that could actually change how his business runs is priced out of his reach. The market quietly decided he is not the customer.

The values gap. Much of the technology world runs on ideas that do not sit well with the people I serve. The idea that your data should live on a company's cloud so it can be studied and sold. The idea that the point of efficiency is to cut jobs. The idea that using the tool means signing up for somebody else's politics along with it. The farmer does not want his records on a server he cannot see. The manufacturer does not want AI that fires his machinists. The classical school does not want tools built on a way of teaching it rejects. None of that is fear of technology. It is ownership, the plain right of a person who owns something to make his own decisions without strings attached.

The trust gap. In a small town, trust is everything. The farmer hires the accountant he knows from church. The manufacturer buys from the supplier he has worked with for fifteen years. What the AI market offers instead is a video call from a city far away and a proposal full of words nobody uses in real life. No handshake, no shared ground, nobody you can look in the eye. The forgotten man is not against technology. He is against trusting people who do not know his world, and he is right to be.

The wrong answer, and the right one

The wrong answer is to sell him a cheap, watered-down version of the big-company product and call it a favor. That closes the money gap by making the other two worse.

The right answer starts from his values and builds forward. If his work and what it produces belong to him, then the records of that work belong to him too, and they should live where he lives: on his own property, under his own lock. If his people are the reason the business exists, then the technology should take the paperwork off their backs, never take their jobs. If nobody knows his operation the way he does, then the tools should learn from his knowledge, not from an average of everybody else's. And because the machine can be confidently wrong, and it can, the machine drafts and the human decides. Every time, with his own name on the final call.

Real tools, built on his values, run on his terms, held in his hands, and judged by whether they actually helped him.

That sentence is the whole business. Everything Liberty Forge does is an attempt to make it true for one shop, one farm, one clinic at a time.

Why this is a paper and not a sales pitch

I could have made this an ad. It would have been shorter. But the forgotten man has been sold to plenty of times, and he can smell a pitch coming a mile off. What he almost never gets handed is an argument: something he can weigh, disagree with, and pass to a neighbor. That is what these papers are for.

AI is going to change the economy. The open question is whether it reaches only the powerful, or whether it also reaches the man who has always done the real work of keeping the country running. It will not reach him by accident. It will reach him because people who share his values decide to build it that way, in his town, with his say-so.

The forge is lit. The iron is hot. The work begins.

Zach Thompson · Liberty Forge AI Consulting · Prairie Roots • National Reach
Why these exist

A body of thought, not content.

The Forge Papers are published one at a time, about monthly, and never to fill a calendar. They are the working convictions behind Liberty Forge: data is property, the human stays in the lead, and efficiency never means a working family loses its living. They are argued in public so a neighbor can weigh them. If one of them changes how you see your own shop, farm, clinic, or classroom, write to me. That is the whole point.